So it is a little late for me to start blogging, but better late than
never. I enjoyed the passing of Arthur, mainly because it brought about
change. I felt that this time period with Arthur as king was a great time
of prosperity and triumph, but it was of tradition. Yes traditions are
great, but sometimes if that is all that is followed then there is no
growth. The kingdom would be stuck in a time where tradition ruled the
day. Like waiting for something to happen before anyone could eat diner,
should had been a tradition that never even started. If I'm hungry, I
better be eating dinner with or without something happening.
Now it is the end of King Arthur's reign and now he must
give his sward back to the Lady of the Lake. Reading this passage again,
I took throwing the sward back into the lake as a chance of rebirth.
Merlin prophesied Arthur would come again, so I looked at this, that because it
was his sward why not place it where no one else can get it. Then when he
comes again, go back and take the sward again.
We also talked about in class how in line 155ish the
sward became a "he", but Arthur describes it as a "he"
first in like 36. I think this is why Sir. Bedivere, and most likely
other knight would call it a "he". If their king did, then they
would follow suit.
For someone that is cut in the head, Arthur does a
really good job at articulating specific details about the things Sir. Bedivere
is supposed to see and hear when he throws the sward into the lake. Literally this would
not be possible. If concussions prevent people from articulating
properly, then a wound "so deeply smitten through the helm" would
certainly immobilize someone.
So I ignored the reality and saw that the wound
represented the inner battles Arthur faced during his life, and that's why the
wound was so deep. Giving up his sward represented accepting that his
reign his over and that he is dead inside.
The symbolism in Sir. Bedivere taking three times could
be compared with the Jesus story with Peter denying knowing Jesus three
times. I interpreted it as Sir. Bedivere seeing the tradition of King
Arthur's kingdom coming down, and all of the people they knew were dying or dead.
I didn't look at the multiple times meaning different things, but that he was
conflicted. If this was going to be the end of Arthur, he wanted to make
sure it was the truth.
At the end of the poem, there were three queens
dressed in black. There is the in three again in the poem. I never
fully understood why there needs to be threes, but there should have been
one. At the end the poem talks about the sun bringing in the New Year. After
thinking, to me it seems like this whole thing took place in the time of the
celebrations Arthur would have. That is just crappy timing for his court
to have to say their goodbyes to their beloved king and have their first
festival without him. Well onwards and upwards and just like this poem is
the end of a tradition, this is the end of my blog post.
That is very interesting, especially looking at Arthur as a person. Even in his death, Arthur's character is not described very much. Despite this, it's easy to see that he may have been a very conflicted person, despite his humble beginnings.
ReplyDeleteThings end. It is often difficult to let go, say "goodbye," and face the end. Change and what happens next might require grief and mourning. Graduating seniors might feel similar ambiguity.
ReplyDeleteIn reference to your confused comment about "threes" of things that kept popping up...I think this is another Christian reference. In Christian writings, there are three entities to God (Jesus, the father and the holy spirit), Jesus rose from the dead after three days, St.Peter denied Jesus three times - and hey , it took Bedeviere three times to throw excalibur into the lake.
ReplyDeleteI think that was just another christian parallel shining through.
yeah, I was just mad that there were so many parallels to the trinity. I understand the reference, but there doesn't need to be 4 different times the trinity is referenced.
DeleteI questioned the head wound myself, especially because the sword had such significance. I didn't think about the time of his passing and how it would have probably been right around a celebration. Many characteristics are discretely shown in this reading in my opinion which leaves us feeling somewhat confused because we have such set opinions on everyone.
ReplyDelete